Published: Wednesday 31st December 2014 by The News Editor
Screening protocols for Ebola will be reviewed after a nurse being treated for Ebola in London was allowed to leave Heathrow even though she was tested repeatedly.
Pauline Cafferkey, a public health nurse at Blantyre Health Centre in South Lanarkshire, is receiving specialist treatment via a quarantine tent at the Royal Free Hospital in north London after initially flying home from Heathrow to Glasgow upon her return from Sierra Leone.
The Government’s chief medical officer Dame Sally Davies said questions have been raised about the airport screening procedure but insisted the screening was designed to raise public awareness about the virus and was not expected to detect every case of Ebola.
She said: “She was cleared to travel because she didn’t have Ebola symptoms including a raised temperature.
“It does raise a question whether we should be more precautionary. The risk of raised temperature when she came back appears to have been very low.
“That’s why we look at what we do all the time to see should we have been more precautionary, is it in the public’s interest? Is it in the patient’s interest?
“I doubt it would have made much difference.”
Meanwhile, head of the Health Protection Agency Dr Paul Cosford told Sky News: “Naturally, we are keen to learn whatever we can from the emerging details of this case and will be reviewing what happened and the screening protocols, to see if anything needs to be changed.”
Dame Sally also said Mrs Cafferkey could be given blood donations from fellow survivors including volunteer Will Pooley in a bid to overcome the deadly virus.
Last night a health care worker in Aberdeen who fell ill following her recent return from west Africa has tested negative for the virus, according to the Scottish Government.
The woman was taken ill on Monday while visiting Torridon in the Scottish Highlands and transferred to Aberdeen Royal Infirmary where she underwent tests.
A third patient from Cornwall who has also recently returned from an affected country is currently in isolation at the Royal Cornwall Hospital in Treliske, Truro, undergoing tests for the virus which has swept through west Africa.
Mrs Cafferkey, who was given the all clear to return to her home despite raising concerns about her temperature, is “doing as well as can be expected in the circumstances”, Scotland’s First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has said.
The experimental drug ZMapp, which was used to treat Mr Pooley, the nurse who was the first UK citizen to contract the disease, is “not available at the moment” according to Dame Sally.
Among options of alternative treatment she said: “We do have available a small amount of convalescent plasma. Plasma is the liquid of blood and convalescent is the recovery phase.
“Will Pooley gave a donation of the plasma and the theory is as we fight off infections we make anti-bodies and if you harvest the plasma you got a source of antibodies that you can put in to someone and you’d expect it to work.
“But the cornerstone of treatment remains fluid and electrolyte treatment.”
The nurse, from Glasgow, was part of a 30-strong team of medical volunteers deployed to Africa by the UK Government last month and had been working with Save the Children at the Ebola Treatment Centre in Kerry Town, Sierra Leone.
She was initially placed in isolation at a Glasgow hospital early on Monday after feeling feverish, before being transferred south on an RAF C-130 Hercules plane.
The healthcare worker had flown from Sierra Leone via Morocco to Heathrow Airport where she was considered a high risk because of the nature of her work and showed no symptoms during screening and a temperature check.
But while waiting for a connecting flight to Glasgow she raised fears about her temperature and was tested a further six times in the space of 30 minutes.
Despite her concerns, she was given the all clear and flew on to Scotland where after taking a taxi home she later developed a fever and raised the alarm.
At a press conference she said she was not aware of reports that Mrs Cafferkey may have attended a Christmas Day church service ahead of her return to the UK, but that a review in to how she contracted the disease will be carried out by the Department for International Development and Save the Children.
Colleague Dr Martin Deahl, who sat next to the nurse on the flight to Heathrow as they returned from five weeks in Sierra Leone, has criticised the procedures in place for testing returning health workers as “disorganised”.
The NHS said 48 volunteer health professionals remain in Sierra Leone helping the thousands of sufferers while a further 1,500 have returned or are preparing to go in stages.
Public Health England and Health Protection Scotland are continuing to trace passengers on the flights Mrs Cafferkey took back to Heathrow via Casablanca in Morocco and her onward journey to Glasgow Airport, where she arrived at about 11.30pm on Sunday on a British Airways flight.
Dr Cosford said as of Tuesday lunchtime around a third of the 133 passengers on board the flight between Morocco and the UK have been contacted while messages have been given to more than half of the 72 travelling between Heathrow and Glasgow.
They have been urged to carefully watch for symptoms of Ebola and given advice on what to do if they present with signs of the virus.
However, he stressed that even passengers who came in to contact with Mrs Cafferkey were at extremely low risk.
“Even though the risk is considered extremely low, as a precaution we are informing people who sat in the direct vicinity of the passengers by which we mean two rows adjacent, ahead and behind them to take their temperature until the 18th of January and if it is raised significantly above 37.5 degrees or they have any concerns are advised to call PHE for advice,” he said.
“That is highly precautionary and I would emphasise again that the risk remains extremely low.
“We can be confident that the risk to the public is low. Ebola cannot be spread easily.”
Sir Bruce Keogh, NHS medical director, added: “From an NHS perspective this has not taken us by surprise.
“We’ve been watching this human tragedy unfold since December 2013 and that’s given us plenty of time to prepare and in our preparations our deliberations have focused mainly on safety.
“Safety for the public, our staff and the patient.”
He added: “In terms of the Royal Free unit it is business as usual in terms of dealing with these very tricky diseases.”
Ebola is not an airborne disease and can only be contracted through contact with bodily fluids including diarrhoea, vomit and blood.
The Royal Free Hospital, a specialist infectious diseases hospital, has the capacity to treat four Ebola patients while Newcastle and Sheffield can care for one each.
Mrs Cafferkey is the second Briton to test positive and the first to do so on UK soil after nurse Mr Pooley, 29, contracted Ebola while volunteering in Sierra Leone in August before getting the all-clear following treatment at the Royal Free Hospital.
She wrote movingly about her experiences in a diary for the Scotland on Sunday newspaper, describing how she had to tell a young boy his mother had died from the virus. His father and sister also died from Ebola, she discovered.
“The sad thing is that this is a regular occurrence and we see and hear of whole families being wiped out by this awful disease,” she wrote.
About 100 people have been tested for the virus in hospitals across England this year, most of whom had visited West Africa.
Enhanced screening was rolled out at some UK airports in October, including Heathrow, with passengers having their temperature taken and completing a questionnaire asking about their current health, recent travel history and whether they had contact with Ebola patients.
Last month, official figures showed 931 people had been assessed in the weeks since the measures were introduced at Heathrow, Gatwick, Birmingham and Manchester airports, plus London St Pancras Eurostar railway station.
Writing in the Guardian, Dr Deahl said he was thankful his colleague took a flight rather than chose to use public transport to get home because the passengers could be traced, while he added he thought there were too few staff carrying out tests on the returning healthcare workers.
He said: “I was surprised we weren’t segregated from other passengers on arrival at Terminal 4. Instead we filed off the plane and walked to immigration just like everybody else. At this point we were escorted to a crowded room next to the arrivals hall for our health check.
“This is when I began to feel uncomfortable. There appeared to be inadequate numbers of staff to deal with us and many queued for an hour waiting to be checked.”
He said he was “devastated” for Mrs Cafferkey but “confident” she would survive, and revealed he believes the greatest risk of possible exposure may have come when volunteers went outside the treatment centres.
“We had complete confidence in our training and equipment and I cannot believe, if proper procedures and protocols were followed, that my friend contracted Ebola while working in the treatment centre.
“We all went out into the local community – some went for early morning runs, and I went to church on Christmas morning – which in hindsight was probably when we were at greatest risk.”
Published: Wednesday 31st December 2014 by The News Editor